Rental Car Crash? New Ruling Limits Who Pays

A black car key fob resting on a surface

If a driver in a rental car hits you, it’s natural to assume the rental company will pay. A new published California appeals decision says that, in many cases, it won’t. The ruling is a reminder to know what coverage you carry before a crash happens.

What did the court decide?

On Oct. 29, 2026, the Second Appellate District, Division One, certified for publication its opinion in O’Brien v. Midway Rent-A-Car, Inc. (case no. B342575). According to the opinion, the plaintiff was in a car accident three days after the rental company leased a car to another driver. He sued both the driver and the company. The trial court granted summary judgment for the rental company, and the Court of Appeal affirmed.

The court answered two questions:

  • Owner liability. California’s Vehicle Code makes a car’s owner vicariously liable for a driver’s negligence when the driver had the owner’s permission (Veh. Code, § 17150). The court held that the federal Graves Amendment preempts that rule when it is applied to a rental company. That federal law says a company that rents or leases vehicles is not liable under state law “by reason of being the owner” of the vehicle, as long as the company itself was not negligent or involved in criminal wrongdoing (49 U.S.C. § 30106(a)).
  • Checking insurance. The court held that a rental company does not have a duty to check whether a renter has auto insurance, and so it can’t be liable for negligent entrustment on that basis alone. The opinion says the court found no California law requiring that check. It also noted that questions about whether rental companies should have to verify renter insurance “should be addressed to the Legislature.”

The opinion applies to the claims made in that case. Whether the decision gets rehearing or further review is something to watch.

Who pays when a rental car driver hurts you?

Under this ruling, the rental company is usually not the first place to look for payment just because it owns the car. In most crashes, the main sources of recovery are these:

  • The driver’s insurance. The driver who caused the crash is the person whose negligence is at issue. Their liability policy, or any coverage that came with the rental, is often the starting point.
  • Your own uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage. The court noted the purpose of this coverage: to put an injured insured person in about the same position they’d be in if the at-fault driver had carried at least the minimum required insurance. The opinion also reasoned that if a rental company leases to an uninsured driver who then injures someone, the injured person’s uninsured motorist coverage can apply because the negligent driver was uninsured.
  • Your own medical payments coverage, if you have it. Check your policy.

If your policy doesn’t include uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage, that gap can matter a great deal after a rental car crash. Pull out your declarations page and see what you have.

Can a rental company ever be responsible?

Yes, in some situations. The Graves Amendment protects an owner from liability that comes only from owning the car. It doesn’t apply when the company itself was negligent or committed criminal wrongdoing (49 U.S.C. § 30106(a)(2)). For example, the claim might be about the company’s own conduct, such as how it maintained the vehicle.

Negligent entrustment is another theory. It looks at whether the company handed over the car to someone whose incompetence, inexperience, or recklessness it knew or should have known about. In this case, the trial court found that the renter had a license, matched the photo, and did not seem unfit to drive. The Court of Appeal said the plaintiff pointed to no evidence of incompetency known to the company. Whether a claim like this works depends on its facts.

How long do you have to bring a claim?

For most personal injury claims in California, the deadline is two years from the date of the injury (Code Civ. Proc., § 335.1). Claims involving a government entity, such as a public vehicle or a road in dangerous condition, can have much shorter deadlines. Waiting can also make it harder to get records and witness accounts.

What should you do after a rental car crash?

These are general steps, not advice for any one situation:

  • Get medical care. Tell the provider how you were hurt. Keep every record and bill.
  • Document the scene. Photos, the other driver’s name, the plate number, the rental company’s name, and witness contact details all help.
  • Get the police report number. Note the agency and the date.
  • Review your own policy. Look for uninsured/underinsured motorist and medical payments coverage, and write down the limits.
  • Be careful with recorded statements. An insurer’s questions may affect how your claim is valued. Know what you’re agreeing to before you give a statement.
  • Keep a simple journal. Note pain, missed work, and how the injury affects your day.

For more on what a crash claim can include, see our Articles & Guides.

Sources