Apria Drivers Waited Too Long to Fight Wage Deal, Court Rules

A plain white envelope on a black background

A California appeals court has ruled that two former Apria Healthcare delivery drivers waited too long to try to step into a $5.75 million wage-and-hour class settlement. In a published opinion filed Nov. 9, 2026, the Third District Court of Appeal affirmed a Sutter County judge’s order turning them away. The court decided only that their request came too late. It did not decide whether the settlement was fair.

For workers, it is a reminder that class action deadlines can start running before you have every detail.

What happened in the Apria case?

According to the opinion, the case, Smith v. Apria Healthcare, started in Sutter County in 2022 as a claim by a licensed vocational nurse. In 2024 it was amended to add delivery drivers who were provided to Apria by staffing agencies. Apria and the plaintiffs agreed to settle for up to $5.75 million, with $977,500 set aside for an estimated 350 delivery drivers.

The two drivers who appealed had their own class action against Apria, filed in Los Angeles in July 2024 and later moved to federal court. Their lawyers had also represented a separate, certified class of Apria drivers in an older Los Angeles case, which the opinion says settled for $16.5 million for 230 class members.

The drivers argued that the Sutter County deal was a collusive “reverse auction.” That is the term for a defendant facing several class actions settling with the lawyers it expects to accept the weakest deal, so that one settlement wipes out the other claims. Their lawyer told the trial court that the per-driver value of the older settlement was nearly 50 times higher. Apria and the plaintiffs in the Sutter County case opposed the request, arguing that it was too late and that there was no basis to grant it. No court has found that the settlement was collusive.

The trial court granted preliminary approval in April 2025, and the claims administrator mailed notice on May 6, 2025. The drivers asked to intervene two days later. The judge denied the request, and the settlement received final approval on Aug. 25, 2025.

Why did the court say they were too late?

A person who wants to join someone else’s lawsuit must ask on “timely application” (Code Civ. Proc., § 387, subd. (d), as quoted in the opinion). The court measured timeliness from the date the drivers knew or should have known their interests were not being adequately protected, not from the date they saw the final settlement terms.

The drivers argued the clock started on April 30, 2025, when they learned of preliminary approval. But their own lawyer said he learned of a possible reverse auction around Aug. 30, 2024, and on Oct. 15, 2024 the drivers told a Los Angeles judge they had “grave concerns” about the Sutter County deal. The court held they knew or should have known their interests were at risk by that October date.

It weighed how far along the case was, the harm the delay caused the settling parties, and the reason for the delay. All three went against the drivers. By the time they asked, the settlement was “rounding third and heading for home,” in the court’s words.

The fight is not entirely over. The opinion notes that a separate appeal by another class member, challenging the denial of her motion to vacate the judgment, is still pending (case C105695). The court expressed no opinion on that appeal.

What does a class action notice mean for you?

In California, a class action settlement needs a judge’s approval after a hearing (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 3.769(a)). The process usually runs in two steps:

  • Preliminary approval. The judge takes a first look at the deal. The order sets the date of the final approval hearing and how the class will be notified (rule 3.769(e)).
  • Final approval. Before approving the deal, the judge must look into whether it is fair (rule 3.769(g)). The notice has to explain the settlement and how to file a written objection or appear at the hearing (rule 3.769(f)).

When class members are allowed to leave the class, the notice must give a deadline and a procedure for asking to be excluded. It must also say that the judgment, good or bad, will bind every member who does not ask to be excluded (rule 3.766(d)).

What are your choices when the notice arrives?

A notice usually gives you three basic choices.

  • Do nothing. You stay in the class. If the judge approves the deal, you are bound by it and usually give up the claims it covers in exchange for your share.
  • Opt out. You leave the class by the deadline. You get no payment from the settlement, but you keep the right to pursue your claims on your own. According to evidence Apria submitted on appeal, the two drivers in this case opted out.
  • Object. You stay in the class but tell the judge why you think the deal is unfair, in writing or at the final hearing, following the steps in the notice.

Asking to intervene, as these drivers did, is a separate and less common step, and the court will look at when you first had reason to worry.

What should you do if you get a notice?

  • Read it the day it arrives and write down every deadline: opt-out, objection, claim form, and the final approval hearing date.
  • Keep the notice and the claims administrator’s contact information.
  • If you already have your own case against the same employer, or a lawyer working on one, tell that lawyer right away. Your options may change once a settlement covers your claims.
  • If something in the notice looks wrong, such as your dates of work or the claims being released, raise it before the deadline, not after.
  • Get advice about your situation before a deadline passes. Missing one can decide your choice for you.

Sources

  • California Court of Appeal, Third District, Smith v. Apria Healthcare (C104113), filed Nov. 9, 2026 (certified for publication): https://www.courts.ca.gov/opinions/documents/C104113.PDF
  • California Rules of Court, rule 3.769 (settlement of class actions): https://courts.ca.gov/cms/rules/index.cfm?title=three&linkid=rule3_769
  • California Rules of Court, rule 3.766 (class notice): https://courts.ca.gov/cms/rules/index.cfm?title=three&linkid=rule3_766
  • California Code of Civil Procedure section 387 (intervention): https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=CCP&sectionNum=387