A California appeals court has ruled that Uber must face a proposed class action over its “upfront price” in court, not in private arbitration. The plaintiffs allege Uber tells riders the price on the screen is what they will pay, then often charges more. The court’s decision turns on a rule that protects consumers who sign app terms.
The First Appellate District, Division Five, published its opinion in Bogguess v. Uber Technologies, Inc. (A174376) on Nov. 4, 2026. It affirmed a San Francisco trial court’s order denying Uber’s motion to compel arbitration (opinion, p. 1-2, 39). The allegations have not been decided by any court.
What do the plaintiffs allege?
Two Uber riders filed a putative class action under California’s Unfair Competition Law (Bus. & Prof. Code, § 17200 et seq.) and False Advertising Law (Bus. & Prof. Code, § 17500 et seq.). According to the complaint, as the court describes it, Uber advertises that the price shown in its app is “the price [the consumer will] pay at the end of the ride.” The plaintiffs allege the displayed price is only an estimate and that Uber “frequently” charges more (opinion, p. 1).
They ask the court to order Uber to stop “advertising prices that are lower than the prices consumers will actually pay,” and to return amounts paid above the displayed price. A “putative” class action is one where no court has yet certified a class, so nobody is a class member at this stage. Uber’s briefing and the court’s opinion do not address whether the allegations are true.
Why did Uber want arbitration?
Riders must accept Uber’s terms of use to use the app. Those terms require users to resolve disputes with Uber individually in arbitration and include a class action waiver. Uber moved to compel arbitration (opinion, p. 2).
Arbitration clauses like this are common in app and subscription terms. They are contracts of adhesion, meaning the user can accept them or not use the service, with no room to negotiate.
What is a public injunction, and why does it matter?
In McGill v. Citibank, N.A. (2017) 2 Cal.5th 945, the California Supreme Court drew a line between two kinds of injunctive relief. Public injunctive relief has “the primary purpose and effect of” prohibiting unlawful acts that threaten future injury to the general public. Relief that mainly redresses harm to an individual, or to a group of people similarly situated to the plaintiff, is private (opinion, p. 8-9, quoting McGill).
McGill held that an arbitration agreement cannot waive the right to seek public injunctive relief in any forum, because that right serves a public purpose (Civ. Code, § 3513, as applied in McGill and quoted in the opinion, p. 9). Uber did not dispute that McGill would bar enforcement of its agreement as to public injunctive relief. It argued that the plaintiffs’ request was private (opinion, p. 10).
The court disagreed. It pointed to the complaint’s allegation that Uber publicly advertises the upfront price and to the request to stop Uber from advertising prices lower than what consumers actually pay. The court concluded the request is for a public injunction (opinion, p. 2, 10-11).
What did the court say about the rest of the case?
Uber’s agreement says that if the class waiver is unenforceable, the affected claims “shall proceed in a court of competent jurisdiction.” Uber argued that the plaintiffs’ claims for their own money should still go to arbitration. The court found the agreement ambiguous on that point and read it against Uber, the drafter, under Civil Code section 1654. It noted the rule applies with particular force to contracts of adhesion (opinion, p. 2-3, 38).
Uber also argued that the Federal Arbitration Act preempts that approach. The court rejected the argument. It reasoned that the rule keeps arbitration unavailable unless a party actually consented to it, which matches the FAA’s focus on consent (opinion, p. 3, 39). The result is that the complaint’s claims stay together in court. The court affirmed the trial court’s order and awarded costs on appeal to the plaintiffs (opinion, p. 39).
What this means for California consumers
- Terms you click through can have limits. Under McGill, a company cannot use an arbitration clause to block a request that a court order it to stop a deceptive practice affecting the public.
- Unclear contract language is read against the company that wrote it. The court applied this rule to a form contract that users could not negotiate.
- Public and private relief are different. A public injunction aims to stop a practice. Getting money back for individuals is a separate kind of relief, and the court kept both in court here.
- Nothing is decided on the merits. The ruling is about where the case is heard. Uber may seek further review, and the allegations remain unproven. Check the court’s docket for the current status of the case.
If you think a business charged you more than it advertised, keep your receipts, screenshots and account records, and save a copy of the terms you agreed to. Every situation depends on its facts, and this article is general information, not legal advice.
Sources
- California Court of Appeal, First Appellate District, Division Five, Bogguess v. Uber Technologies, Inc. (A174376), filed Nov. 4, 2026, certified for publication: opinion (PDF)
- McGill v. Citibank, N.A. (2017) 2 Cal.5th 945, as quoted in the Bogguess opinion above.
- Civ. Code, §§ 1654, 3513, as quoted in the Bogguess opinion above.


